1555-1559: Breton England
The years 1555-1559 saw the question of Henry IX's controversial succession continue to agitate the kingdom of England, until it was brutally resolved.
1555 was a special year for Elizabeth I and Edward VI. The two sovereigns continued to consolidate their authority, relying in particular on Parliament to consolidate their legitimacy. Their desire to consolidate their lineage was reinforced by the birth of Prince Henry, heir to the crown, in February 1555. In addition to this quest to strengthen their position on the throne, they pursued the policies put in place since Elizabeth I came to power.
But these successes were met with challenges and complications that jeopardized their presence on the English throne. The implementation of an enclosure policy was hampered by opposition from the English lords who practiced it, while economic tensions continued to plague various regions. Despite the birth of Prince Henry, the English court remained divided, with various factions including English lords and clergymen in favor of Mary. Relations with the clergy worsened in 1555 as a result of the succession controversy, and were aggravated in the summer of 1555 by the excommunication of Elizabeth I and her husband, creating further fault lines within the court and contributing to the emergence of positions close to the Lutheran, Calvinist and Tyndalian movements. The temptation to distance himself from Rome was strengthened by Clement VIII's refusal to accede to a demand from part of parliament to tax monasteries. The two sovereigns were supported in this by the Queen Dowager and part of the Privy Council, including Thomas Cranmer, but others were reserved or opposed to the idea of supporting the taxation of monasteries. Financial and religious issues took a back seat to diplomatic ones, however, and the succession controversy continued to divide the English nobility and gentry, right up to Parliament. Despite the failure of Henry Pole's conspiracy, Mary's supporters reorganized, benefiting from the support of several prominent English clergymen. In the face of these challenges, Elizabeth I was urged by her entourage to distance herself from Rome and establish her authority over the Church of England, notably by following the example of Gustav I of Sweden. From the autumn of 1555, a project to nationalize Church property was underway, and Elizabeth's allies undertook to defend it in Parliament.
On the diplomatic front, Elizabeth I and her husband worried about the risk of invasion, while the marriage of James VI of Scotland to Catherine of Brittany in the spring of 1555 contributed to the isolation of their kingdom. They sought allies, but the neutrality or opposition of some of their neighbors made the search for allies complicated. Their relations with Charles IX of France deteriorated with his clearer support for Marie's claims, while the pension to the English crown ceased to be paid in the summer of 1555. Faced with the risk of attack by the Duke of Brittany or the King of France, Elizabeth I and Edward VI had their coasts watched and the Calais garrison reinforced to protect it from possible attack. Rumors of an expedition by the Duke of Brittany and his wife at the end of 1555 prompted the royal couple to order their fealty to be extremely vigilant. They considered carrying out a pre-emptive attack against the Breton fleet, but abandoned the project to avoid coming into conflict with Charles IX at a time when they had no allies to counter the latter. The royal couple also had to deal with the conflict dividing the O'Neills as they maintained their support for Conn O'Neill and Shane O'Neill, allying themselves with Sorely McDonnell and receiving support from Thomas Butler to confront his father and brother Feardorcha during this period.
Faced with Elizabeth I and her entourage, her opponents rallied around Mary, notably the lords who had gone into exile after the failure of the 1553 conspiracy, and a few representatives of Irish lords eager to obtain Mary's support in defending their interests. Through the English princess and her husband Francis IV of Brittany, the Marianists sought the support of powerful allies, not only the King of France, because of his links with the Duke of Brittany and his wife, but also other powers. They could take advantage of the prosperity of the Duchy of Brittany to build up a force to complement those that Francis IV of Brittany or Charles IX of France could add to their ranks. The excommunication of Elizabeth I and Edward VI gave them the opportunity to work with Mary and Francis IV on an expedition to place the princess on the English throne. The news of Elizabeth I's planned takeover of the Church of England gave Mary and her allies a new weapon with which to assert her claims and legitimacy.
The beginning of 1556 saw events come to a head: Mary and Francis IV were preparing a large fleet to embark an army. They commissioned Thomas Butler to lead a new insurrection in Ireland to distract their adversaries. Butler disembarked in Ireland in the spring of 1556 with a small armed force and set about seizing the County of Ormonde, over which he had claims, before asking the Irish lords to rally to Mary's side, promising less interference by the English crown in the island's affairs. While some lords remained neutral, others like Shane O'Neill and Sorely McDonnell sided with Thomas Butler, while others like Gerald FitzGerald of Desmond and Conn O'Neill opposed him and supported Thomas Radclyffe against the insurgents. Violent clashes broke out in Tír Eoghain and Ormonde County in April and May 1556, as the English crown sent reinforcements to support the Lord-Lieutenant and prevent an invasion of the island by Mary and her allies. Thanks to these reinforcements, the Lord-Lieutenant managed to defeat Thomas Butler's forces near Carlow in mid-May 1556, but failed to neutralize Shane O'Neill despite another devastating campaign in Ulster.
Taking advantage of the unrest in Ireland, in May 1556 Mary and Francis IV embarked with their allies in a fleet of around 100 ships, accompanied by an armed force of 7,000, most of them Bretons, but also a few English, Welsh and Irish, and mercenaries recruited by the Duke of Brittany in the preceding months. Although they feared running into ships from the fleets of Elizabeth I and Edward VI, Marie and her husband's fleet managed to cross the English Channel without any unpleasant surprises. Mary and Francis IV disembark near Poole on May 16, 1556. Marie announced her intention to reclaim the throne and called for rallies on her behalf. On May 17, they faced a force from Devon, which they quickly neutralized at Bere Regis. After this initial skirmish, Marie and her allies strengthened their forces in the region, leaving Poole on May 19. Mary and her allies supported a northward advance to strengthen their forces and establish her legitimacy, rather than march directly on London. This led Mary and her husband to Salisbury on May 23, before reaching Marlborough on May 26, 1556. As a result of rallies, notably from Dorset thanks to its former Earl Henri Pole, the forces of Mary and her allies numbered around twelve thousand men when they left Marlborough for Oxford, which they reached on May 29, 1556. They were supported by John de Vere, Earl of Oxford, and prepared as they learned of the approach of Edward VI's forces to the north.
Warned on May 18 of the landing of Francis IV and Mary's forces, Elizabeth I and Edward VI set about gathering their forces to repel their adversaries. Mobilizing their forces was difficult, however, due to the fact that some of their forces had already been sent to Ireland, and that the two sovereigns were uncertain about the loyalty of some of the English nobility and gentry, especially as they learned of Dorset's rallying to the Marian cause. The Duke of Suffolk and the Earl of Warwick were joined by the Earl of Worcester, William Somerset. On May 27, 1556, Edward VI joined the armed forces led by John Dudley and Henry Suffolk, while George Boleyn and Henry Howard were charged with protecting London and Elizabeth I. The forces of Edward VI and his allies left Northampton on the 28th and descended on Oxford to stop Mary and Francis IV.
On June 2, 1556, the two armies faced each other near Bicester. The two armies were fairly evenly matched: thirteen thousand men for the army of Mary and Francis IV, sixteen thousand for those of Edward VI. Francis IV could rely on a fairly experienced force, while Edward VI could rely on allies determined to counter what was perceived as a foreign attack. The battle between the two sides was brutal and uncertain, with William Worcester and his forces failing to outflank Francis IV's forces and being halted by John de Vere's forces. The cannons of Francis IV's forces play a crucial role in the battle, as Henry Suffolk's forces press the forces of Henry Pole, made up in part of Dorset volunteers. Francis IV instructs the Swiss pikemen accompanying him to halt his opponent's attack. The situation changes when Francis IV attempts a charge to outflank Henry Suffolk's forces. Edward VI's forces try to stop the charge, whose aim is to cut off their retreat to London or Northampton. During the fighting, Edward VI and Francis IV almost clashed. The experience of Francis IV's Breton and French forces eventually made the difference in the charge and dislocated Edward VI's forces. The latter was almost captured and withdrew with part of his forces to Northampton, while John Dudley was killed and Henry Suffolk captured. By the end of the battle, the forces of Francis IV and his allies had lost almost a thousand men, while Edward VI's forces had been reduced by around five thousand men killed, wounded or taken prisoner. Edward VI reorganized his remaining forces before retreating to London to face the advance of Mary and her allies, while an insurrection led by Thomas Percy broke out in the north.
Success at Bicester allowed Mary and Francis IV to consolidate their position and threaten London. Determined to exploit their success, the princess and her husband considered descending on London, but decided to pursue Edward VI to prevent him from raising new forces. They reached Northampton on June 7, 1556, but had to lay siege to the city on June 8 and 9 as Edward VI escaped to Bedford. They did, however, receive the support of Thomas Percy, son of the last deposed and executed Earl of Northumberland, who had risen up against Elizabeth I and Edward VI in mid-February. Pursuing Edward VI and the rest of his forces, Mary and her allies reached Bedford on June 12, before moving closer to London. Reinforced by the new rallies and the arrival of Thomas Percy's forces, their forces numbered around fourteen thousand men by the time they reached Cambridge on June 13. However, they learned of an attempted attack on Salisbury by Elizabeth I's loyalists on June 14, 1556. This attack led them to reinforce their forces, while at the same time instructing their allies to seek to consolidate their position in the kingdom, particularly with the Welsh and Irish. Reginald Pole accompanied Thomas Percy north to establish the couple's authority in the northern provinces and make contact with the Scots. Mary and Francis IV were reluctant to descend on London, however, unwilling to risk a siege in the event of opposition from the city, but not wanting to see Elizabeth I and her family escape. On June 16, 1556, Mary decided to descend on London with her husband and the bulk of the forces supporting her, and commissioned John de Vere and Arthur Pole to cross the Thames further west in an attempt to cut off the southern route to their adversaries. The Earl of Oxford and the nephew of the Earl of Salisbury crossed the Thames at Marlow on June 22, 1556, before reaching Richmond on June 24. They almost intercepted Elizabeth I and her entourage, but found themselves facing part of George Boleyn's forces at Southwark on June 25, 1556.
Edward VI reached London on June 13, joining forces with Henry Brandon and Henry Howard and his wife and their family. The royal couple planned to defend the capital against their adversaries, the Duke of Suffolk's and Duke of Norfolk's forces numbering around two thousand men and the forces that had accompanied Edward VI after the defeat at Bicester and the desertions around eight thousand. These intentions were hampered, however, by the growing tensions within the capital as Mary and Francis IV drew closer to it, while at the same time strengthening their forces through various rallies. Added to these constraints was the increasingly uncertain support of parliament, as the clergy sided more and more with Marie. Faced with a deteriorating situation, Edward VI and Elizabeth I planned exile and began to prepare their escape, but refused advice from their entourage to leave London quickly to avoid losing what support they still had in the capital.
Mary and her allies left Cambridge on June 17 and descended on London. Their forces reached the outskirts of London on June 21, 1556. Marie asked to negotiate the submission of the city and the surrender of Elizabeth I and Edward VI. She met representatives of her half-sister and the city near the priory of Saint-Barthélemy-le-Grand on June 22, 1556. The representatives of Elizabeth I and Edward VI were reluctant to accept Mary's terms, seeking to buy time to facilitate the escape of the royal couple and their children. The aldermen representing London were more sympathetic to the princess's arguments. The presence of various representatives of the nobility alongside Mary and her husband had an impact on the positions of the representatives of Elizabeth I and the city, reinforcing the divisions within parliament, which no longer seemed certain of supporting Elizabeth I and Edward VI. The first negotiations led Elizabeth I and Edward VI to want to protect their family, while the risk of forfeiture and the threat of insurrection within London became significant. News of the advance of Arthur Pole and John de Vere's forces precipitated Elizabeth I and her husband's decision to leave London. Instructing George Boleyn to cover their departure, the couple and their children left the city on the night of June 23-24, 1556. George Boleyn maintained the presence of his forces in London throughout late June 1556, but had to deal with a rebellion in certain parts of London when rumors of the royal couple's disappearance spread, raising questions and concerns among the population. The Duke of Somerset also had to deal with the risk of being cut off from Elizabeth I and Edward VI. On June 25, part of his forces confronted the Earl of Oxford's forces at Southwark and drove them back, protecting the escape of Elizabeth I and Edward VI.
Mary and her allies learn of the rumors and the departure of Elizabeth I and her husband on June 26, 1556. Mary sought to exploit this news as she met again with representatives from London on June 27, stressing that the flight of those claiming to be their sovereigns was contrary to their duties. This meeting, the influence of the local clergy and the approach of John de Vere's forces precipitated events with George Boleyn forced to flee London during the riot of June 28, 1556, which saw London open its doors to Mary and Francis IV. Mary consolidated her position in the capital, while Francis IV joined John de Vere on June 29. The two men pursued the Duke of Somerset and sought to catch up with Elizabeth I and Edward VI. Their forces clashed with George Boleyn's near Dartford on July 1, 1556. The Duke of Somerset tried to resist the Duke of Brittany and the Duke of Oxford despite the numerical inferiority of his forces, before the pressure of his adversaries led to the rout of his forces and his capture. Francis IV and John de Vere joined Rochester, who surrendered to them on July 3, 1556.
Elizabeth I and Edward VI first reached Rochester on June 26. They prepared their departure and anticipated the risk of attack from their adversaries, seeking to rely on forces loyal to them in Kent. They considered reaching Dover, but were dissuaded by the risk of running into French ships. On learning of the fall of London on June 29, they set about preparing their departure. A disagreement emerged over the destination of exile: Edward VI and Henry Howard defended the choice of the Spanish Netherlands, but Anne Boleyn disagreed, not least because Eleanor of Habsburg was Mary's cousin. In the end, the choice was made to attempt to reach the more neutral Kingdom of Denmark, although Anne Boleyn's opponents suspected her of having supported this destination because of the Lutheran Church. On July 1, 1556, a flotilla was completed, enabling Elizabeth and her entourage to embark. The flotilla managed to leave the Medway on July 2, and was almost attacked by ships in the service of Mary and Francis IV off the Hoo peninsula. Narrowly escaping the confrontation, Elizabeth I and her entourage made their way through the North Sea, where crossing conditions were complicated. The flotilla was forced to stop in The Hague on July 6, 1556. Elizabeth I and Edward VI were struck by mourning with the death of Prince Henry on July 9, 1556, the young prince having fallen ill during the crossing. This loss delayed the departure of the small flotilla, which almost prevented Elizabeth I and Edward VI from leaving The Hague as the authorities tried to prevent them from leaving. They finally left in a hurry on July 12, 1556. They reached the island of Bant, controlled by the county of East Friesland, on July 13. They were welcomed by the regent, Anne of Oldenburg, in Emdem on July 16. Welcomed as best they could by the regent and her three sons, Edzard, John and Christopher, the entourage of the fallen royal couple recuperated from the trip and reflected on what to do next. Joining the Kingdom of Denmark remained a possibility, given its proximity to the Duchy, although the uncertainty of Christian III's reception due to his policy of neutrality was a potential obstacle. Any attempt to reconquer the English throne is ruled out for the time being, due to the lack of means to succeed and the fact that the French alliance is likely to be resurrected by Marie due to her ties. While the county of East Friesland is prosperous and can be a valuable ally, its proximity to the Spanish Netherlands makes it an uncertain territory to remain in for the long term. The latent conflict over Harlingerland, which had involved the county for many years, also resurfaced during the period, with the conquest of the Accum Depression by Count John II "the Terrible" of Harlingerland. This conflict led Anne of Oldenburg to appeal to the Imperial Chamber and the Circle of Lower Rhine-Westphalia, but she had to ask her guests to leave, as their presence could create constraints and difficulties for her. They left the county of East Frisia in August 1556 and, after a difficult crossing, reached Husum in mid-August 1556. They were soon welcomed by Christian III. Although reluctant because of his religious convictions and policy of neutrality, the Danish sovereign eventually granted them hospitality, allowing them to stay at Plön Castle, rebuilt since the War of the Two Kings. The exiles spent the next few years preparing for their return, but had to cope with Christian III's lack of support for them and the difficulties of living despite the pension granted by the Danish sovereign. Their exile was complicated by religious disagreements, with Anne Boleyn expressing her views more openly, while Edward de Courtenay was more reserved and cautious, given the possibility of a return to England. The exile was brightened by the birth of Princess Gertrude in March 1558.
After their success against Elizabeth I and Edward, and despite their failure to capture the couple and their children, Mary and Francis IV work to strengthen their authority in England and to resolve the various problems and challenges they face in the summer of 1556. They first sought to neutralize the potential threats that remained in the kingdom, notably by granting amnesty to those who would submit to their authority. In this way, they secured the submission of Henry Howard, who was released at the beginning of August 1556. Only Devon continued to be troubled during the late summer of 1556, prompting Mary and her husband to send forces to restore order and quell insurrections. Mary could count on the support of her allies and several prominent representatives of the English clergy to establish her authority and legitimize her seizure of power. She also worked to secure the support of Parliament, playing on the flight and exile of her half-sister and the respect of the rules of succession. However, she faced a major challenge from representatives of parliament and the nobility: the question of her husband Francis IV's status. The English barons' apprehension at seeing a French prince on the English throne was considerable, even if this concern was tempered by the fact that he was Duke of Brittany and that certain lords in the south of the kingdom had forged important ties with him. The lords' concerns were also echoed by Charles IX, King of France, through his ambassador, who conveyed the sovereign's requests and thoughts to Mary and her husband at the end of July 1556. Determined to consolidate their position on the throne, Mary and Francis IV undertook to take account of Parliament, and Francis was first considered consort before sovereign, due to his position as duke in the kingdom of France. Mary and her husband also confirmed their commitments made at the Amboise meeting concerning the English and Breton succession.
All their efforts won the support of the representatives of Parliament in early August 1556. They invalidated Elizabeth I and Edward VI as sovereigns and confirmed Mary as the rightful Queen of England, with Francis IV of Brittany as consort. Mary was crowned at Westminster in the second half of August 1556. Shortly after her coronation, she stripped the titles and estates of those close to Elizabeth I and Edward VI, leading in particular to the abolition of the title of Duke of Devon and the recovery of George Boleyn's titles by the Queen. The Queen redistributed some of these estates to her allies, restoring the title of Earl of Salisbury to Henry Pole. She appointed Reginald Pole as Chancellor in recognition of his support for her. She and her Privy Council worked to reorganize the kingdom, partly adopting the policies of Elizabeth I and Edward VI. They relied heavily on Parliament, not least to consolidate their authority in the face of continuing opposition within the kingdom. They adopted the commercial policy of their predecessors, taking advantage of the special ties with the Duchy of Brittany and seeking to build on trade relations with the Spanish Netherlands. However, they had to deal with the problem of enclosures. However, they were able to benefit from a resumption of the pension paid by the French crown from the summer of 1557, following the meeting between Mary I and Charles IX at Guînes in April 1557 to reaffirm the ties between the two kingdoms and confirm by treaty the conditions agreed at the Amboise meeting, notably on the question of English and Breton succession.
On the dynastic front, Marie I had her eldest son Francis brought to England to train and prepare him for his position as crown prince. Her second son Henri remained in France as heir to the Duchy of Brittany, trained by his father when he returned to manage his estates, or by his advisors in his absence. The future Duke of Brittany also spent time at the French court, providing Charles IX with a guarantee that the Duchy of Brittany would not become detached from the kingdom. Aware of the need to consolidate her son's position as heir to the crown, Mary I undertook to choose him an English wife to consolidate his position at court and develop the confidence of the kingdom's representatives in him. The matrimonial question gave rise to some controversy between her and Francis IV, as the Duke of Brittany had intended his son to marry a French princess or a princess of Navarre. In the end, however, Francis IV conceded the decision to his wife. She chose Anne Pole, niece of the Earl of Salisbury and daughter of the late Geoffroy Pole. The marriage between the two young men was arranged in October 1557. The wife of the heir to the crown became pregnant in 1558 and gave birth to a son in September 1558, whom she and Francis named Arthur.
Although she succeeded in strengthening her authority in the kingdom thanks to her abilities and the support of her advisors and husband, Mary I had to contend with a number of plots and attempted insurrections in favor of her half-sister during the late 1550s. The most serious attempt occurred in Kent in April 1557, when Thomas Wyatt the Younger tried to provoke an insurrection in favor of Elizabeth and Edward. Thanks to the actions of the Grand Sheriff of Kent and the intervention of Henry Pole, the attempt was foiled, and Thomas Wyatt was arrested and executed for conspiracy and treason in June 1557. Thomas Wyatt's attempt precipitated the marriage of Prince Francis to Anne Pole. Apart from this attempt at insurrection, other attempts fizzled out for lack of support.
From a religious point of view, Mary I followed her father's and half-brother's policy of putting an end to potential Protestant movements in the kingdom. In her project to consolidate her legitimacy, Mary also relied on leading representatives of the English clergy, such as Stephen Gardiner and Reginald Pole. She disagreed, however, with her husband Francis IV on the question of developing a similar policy in France, on the need to consolidate royal authority over the local clergy, the sovereign being reluctant to strain her relations with the papacy even though Clement VIII's support had been invaluable. However, she had to take account of parliament's expectations, and from 1558 onwards she began to obtain the possibility of taxing monasteries from the Papacy. The strengthening of her ties with the Papacy was not well received by some court officials, who feared a return to papal interference in the kingdom, while the Church of England project of Elizabeth I and Edward VI continued to arouse the interest of some parts of the court and the kingdom's elites.
Among the issues requiring swift resolution, Mary I sought to resolve the various troubles affecting the lands of Ireland. She granted the title of Earl of Ormonde to Thomas Butler in August 1556, and commissioned him to escort Thomas Radclyffe to the Emerald Isle to help resolve the conflicts between the various Irish lords. Thomas Radclyffe returned to London in July 1556 to pay homage to the new sovereign. Mary I and her husband kept him in the position of Lord-Lieutenant of Ireland, but instructed him to resolve the troubles between the various Irish lords more diplomatically, before employing his tactics. Marie reverses the decisions of her two predecessors concerning the succession to Tír Eoghain, despite Thomas Radcyffe's disagreement. This decision gave Shane O'Neill the support of the English, but provoked more head-on opposition from Conn O'Neill and his son Feardorcha, the lesser king of Tír Eoghain being determined to defend his choice of successor. Unrest between Shane O'Neill and his relatives continued to affect Tír Eoghain throughout 1557, before Thomas Radclyffe intervened to force Conn O'Neill to accept the traditional succession by tanistria. This did not, however, bring an end to tensions, as Shane was nearly killed in the spring of 1558. The situation was only resolved by the suspicious death of Feardorcha in the summer of 1558, followed by the death of Conn O'Neill the following year, allowing Shane O'Neill to become the new ruler of Tír Eoghain.
Thomas Radclyffe also had to intervene in the troubles that once again affected the small kingdom of Thomond during this period: Dermod O'Brien died in 1557, leading to renewed conflict over the succession, as Dermod's son, Murchadh, was a child. Donnell O'Brien took advantage of the situation to become the new King of Thomond, with the support of the Dál gCais. Thomas Radclyffe is forced to recognize Donnell's new position, although it is contested by Connor O'Brien, his nephew, who claims the position because his father, Donough, had been the designated heir of Conchobhar mac Toirdhealbaig. At Mary I's request, Thomas Radclyffe endeavored to maintain peace in the region while striking a balance between the various Irish lords.
The change of English ruler led the Irish lords to hope for a return to the state they had enjoyed before Henry VIII's death. Although Mary I's Irish policy interfered less in their affairs than it had under her half-sister, the Lord-Lieutenant retained the powers he had acquired in recent years, and did not hesitate to intervene in conflicts between Irish lords to bring them to an end. The Lord-Lieutenant could count on the support of Thomas Butler, even if the latter had to deal with his family's rivalry with the FitzGeralds of Desmond. Marie I thus retained the consequent influence developed by her two predecessors on the island, but worked to develop better relations with the Irish lords.
On the diplomatic front, the years 1556-1559 saw Mary I forge relations with her various neighbors. While she developed important relations with Charles IX of France and James VI of Scotland, meeting the latter in the autumn of 1557, she also turned her attention to the Habsburgs. She developed ties with Eleanor of Habsburg as part of the economic and commercial relations linking the Spanish Netherlands to the Kingdom of England. The death of Charles V in 1556 led Mary I to forge ties with Philip II of Spain. She also forged ties with John II of Norway, as part of her economic exchanges and to protect herself from the continuing threat posed by her half-sister. Finally, she strengthened her relations with the papacy and Clement VIII.