alternatehistory.com
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
New profile posts
New threadmarks
Latest activity
Members
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Word Count:
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Members
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Salvador79's latest activity
Salvador79
reacted to
Madhukar_Shah's post
in the thread
How would India deal with its caste system if the East India Company didn't take over
with
Like
.
It very much depends on which states are emerging into modernity and how they go about it- different parts of India will go different...
Yesterday at 2:47 AM
Salvador79
reacted to
Nuraghe's post
in the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
with
Like
.
To conclude my reasoning, certainly someone could affirm that to consolidate or grow imperial power in Italy, it was necessary in some...
Friday at 1:24 PM
Salvador79
reacted to
Nuraghe's post
in the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
with
Like
.
Very true, also for the simple fact that in the long run the Italians tried several times to be included in the imperial project, but...
Friday at 9:46 AM
Salvador79
replied to the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
.
Absolutely, I agree. The linguistic / proto-nationalist element certainly wasn't strong yet, but some very first tendencies, maybe.
Friday at 8:46 AM
Salvador79
reacted to
Nuraghe's post
in the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
with
Like
.
I agree again with your analysis, in fact I am of the opinion that the investiture controversy was not really a fundamental clash that...
Friday at 8:43 AM
Salvador79
replied to the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
.
I mean, if @John Fredrick Parker is hell-bent on having the HREmperor prevail (which I don't say you are - just in case you WERE), he...
Friday at 8:16 AM
Salvador79
reacted to
Nuraghe's post
in the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
with
Like
.
I completely agree with your comment, in reality I am personally of the opinion that getting one of the two contenders to win the...
Friday at 6:50 AM
Salvador79
replied to the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
.
All of these PoDs could massively influence the Investiture Controversy, sure. In my TL, the different Investiture Controversy (actually...
Friday at 6:00 AM
Salvador79
reacted to
Nuraghe's post
in the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
with
Like
.
certainly it can be an effective development, but it must be considered that if the Normans were less successful in their Italian...
Friday at 1:42 AM
Salvador79
reacted to
John Fredrick Parker's post
in the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
with
Love
.
Actually, going back to the 1066 PoDs for a sec -- I am checking out a TL on the subject now, and it actually makes a fair case that the...
Friday at 1:40 AM
Salvador79
reacted to
Nuraghe's post
in the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
with
Like
.
Let's start with your first question, yes indeed the Normans and the Salians also entered into conflict with each other quite quickly...
Friday at 1:35 AM
Salvador79
reacted to
John Fredrick Parker's post
in the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
with
Like
.
Was the Canossa really such a power player in its own right? I mean, I know it's where Adelaide fortified herself when she invited the...
Friday at 1:34 AM
Salvador79
reacted to
Nuraghe's post
in the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
with
Like
.
So the question is actually extremely interesting, but we must understand that at least 4 problems already exist that can hinder this...
Friday at 1:33 AM
Salvador79
reacted to
John Fredrick Parker's post
in the thread
AHC & WI No / Alt Investiture Controversy
with
Like
.
It seems like it’s been years since we had a thread discussing church reformism in the late 11th Century (last I found), and even longer...
Friday at 1:30 AM
Salvador79
reacted to
alexmilman's post
in the thread
AHC: Make the world stagnate in the Middle Ages
with
Like
.
Indeed. But periods of collapse and regress had been happening here and there from time to time and collapse of a major culture was...
Thursday at 2:31 PM
Members
Top